Jabberwock...y? What's that? [Pretend you're surprised he's never read Alice in Wonderland.] This is definitely an island though. Or well...a cluster of six islands, technically. It's a tourist spot, apparently.

But no, not necessarily, remember what I just said? Our memories have been tampered with. Technically, none of us know for sure what we were doing when we were kidnapped or when it actually happened. And it's not exactly hard to knock somebody unconscious and kidnap them.

[May or may not be speaking from first hand experience here. From both sides of the equation, honestly.]